61 Comments

  1. I love the design of the sharpener – I especially love the color. Kinda reminds me of a green chalk board from elementary school. It also reminds me of a handheld flashlight or something similar. And since I’ve never seen one in person, I love that it looks solid and reliable. I’m gonna have to buy one!

  2. I have 2 of these and volunteer at a elementary school. I brought one in and the teachers want them. So, I got a couple more and I got an idea of how to mount them I used 3/16th inch steel round and went through the bottom two hole a piece about 7 inches long and used fence U nails and hammered one side down on a 2 X 8
    board and the hammered down the other side that thing was not going anywhere the board was about 10 inches long I painted one RED a little hard to hide…….
    The teachers Love it……. Thanks Mr. Decoff

    • I have mixed results myself. Some broke mercilessly; some not — even from the same manufacturer. I generally don’t use anything “longer” than the KUM wedge for those, though. This sharpener might be great for Verithins, but I haven’t tried yet.

  3. Thanks, John, for your feedback about the colored pencils. I have young kids and we’re about to graduate from the bits and pieces of old pencils I had around the house to something nicer, but our current crank sharpener will eat them up, and handheld sharpeners take a little more finesse (and patience). I guess I’ll give this sharpener a try, and if it doesn’t work we’ll just have to work on our pencil-sharpening skills. :)

    • My pleasure! : )
      You can’t go wrong with a KUM wedge for colored pencils, unless you like a really sharp point. In my experience, they’re second only to a knife in avoiding breakages.

  4. adair

    Well, thanks to your review, I purchased one of these, and I have to say, it is as good as the legendary Carl Decade, except that instead of plastic, it is cased in metal. The similarities otherwise are close enough to make me wonder if this sharpener isn’t manufactured by Carl or at least in Japan. (There is no country of origin or manufacturing name that I could find, but the plastic box in which it comes is very similar to some of the Carls sold at Kinokuniya.) Clean sharp points, perfect in every way—you will not find a better sharpener.

      • I think that this is, indeed, a Carl sharpener. I’ve been trying to find a good desktop sharpener (since Bundoki are sold out of the Carls) and today on eBay I found a Carl Angel A-5 that looks identical to this one. It’s available in both the green shown above and quite a nice blue (both links are to eBay; no affiliation to the sellers, just for illustrative purposes).

        Since it’s so cheap, even with shipping included, and I’m almost certain it’s the same sharpener as the one reviewed above, I’m going to buy one. I’ll report back when I receive it.

          • The sharpener I linked to previously is definitely the same as the one you reviewed. The points it produces, and the sharpener itself, are the same as those in the photos above. As I said in reply to Adair, below, it looks like these are produced in China by the same company, then rebadged by various manufacturers; so far, I’ve seen the Classroom Friendly version, several Carl Angel version (red, black, green, and blue), and also a Helix version in red.

            As Adair says, at the price these are selling for, it’s definitely worth picking up a couple of them — one for each place you have a desk to attach it to, basically. And with the various colours available, there’s no shortage of colour-coördination options open to you.

  5. Very interesting – thank you for the review. Although I have more sharpeners than really necessary (including two DE-100, my favourite) I couldn’t resist to order a blue A-5 because of its metal case and retro look. In this case, I am also willing to accept bite marks when using it.

    Speaking of the DE-100: A comparison of the DE-100’s mechanism with the one of the reviewed sharpener shows an important difference. In the DE-100, the toothing that drives the burr unit is made of plastic while the other seems to be made of metal – a clear sign that the latter is built for heavier use.

  6. adair

    Koralatov,thanks for the proof that these are indeed Carls. I suspected as much. In light of this, the price that Troy is asking for these sharpeners is especially reasonable, a real bargain. Carls are usually $30 plus postage from Japan. And these are metal versions, not plastic! It is worth getting more than one.

    • Despite the Royal Mail’s best efforts at not delivering my sharpener (long story), I finally got it. It’s wonderful, and definitely the same one as the Classroom Friendly Sharpener. Having used it for a couple of days now, it’s hard to believe I ever got by without it — the points it produces are just wonderful, and a real joy to write with. Now that I’ve tested this firsthand, I’m going to buy another couple of them — one for my desk at work, another for my bag.

      A little more investigation — searching eBay for “a5 sharpener”, basically — leads me to believe that this isn’t actually manufactured by Carl. I think it’s manufactured in China by… someone, then rebadged by various manufacturers; I saw a Helix version on eBay as well, for about the same price.

      If you search eBay for “carl angel sharpener”, you can find the sharpener in red, green, blue, and black, so there are plenty of colour options available. I’ll probably get a couple of different colours myself, though the blue is quite nice.

      • I should have clarified in my previous comment that the seller I bought my sharpener from — joannelau81 on eBay — shipped this incredibly quickly, and it was in the UK about four days after I ordered it; unfortunately, I wasn’t in to receive the delivery the day it arrived, and the Royal Mail managed to botch the redelivery on four separate occasions. I had to go and collect it in person in the end.

  7. I contact Mr. Decoff of Classroom Friendly Supplies to ask if the Blue sharpeners were from him and he said no. He at this time only sells the Green one. He is not sure if the blue one is the same as his has the longer lasting metal gears as opposed to the plastic gears. He told me he has had his for almost 7 years.
    I asked as some of the teachers wanted to know if there were different colors.
    He did say he had a cute Blue “Beetle Car” one but it was not as durable as the green. (very good though) and works in the same fashion.

    • The blue Carl version I bought has the same metal gear inside it as the green version reviewed here. As I said in my other comments on this review, I’m totally certain that this is manufactured by the same company as Mr. Decoff’s Classroom Friendly Sharpener. I’m not sure who exactly manufacturers it, but the Carl, CRF, and Helix models are all identical; the auction for the Helix model said it was made in China.

      • Anne

        We have the red Carl one (in the Philippines) and it looks identical to the one being reviewed. It lasted two years with three people using it in a homeschool setting. The first thing to go was the clamp that attached it to the table. It just lost it’s ability to grip over time, but as the reviewer said, since the sharpener holds the pencil for you, that’s not a big deal. Other issues, though, is that it won’t grip pencils made of recycled newspaper, which I’ve recently switched to to make it clear which pencils are mine and which are the kids’. I can still get it to sharpen them, I just have to hold the sharpener with my left hand so that I can use my last two fingers to push the plate that holds the pencil in toward the sharpener. But now it has started to sharpen the pencils crookedly. Two years is the longest we’ve had a sharpener last for us so far, including expensive electric models, so I’m not too broken up about it, but I think I’m going to pick up a vintage Boston KS from eBay to replace it.

  8. Whoa…mine is here already! Arrived yesterday, in fact. Holy smokes, that was fast!

    First impressions are highly favorable. I’ll likely post a few short thoughts on my blog over the weekend, though not a full out review. That’s been done very nicely already. ;)

    Definitely yet another pencil accessory I wish I’d had growing up!

  9. If that sharpener is really made by Carl I wonder if the inner parts of the clamping are compatible to the ones in the DE-100 and BR-05. In other words: If the soft clamping jaws of these two plastic models fit into the metal one shown here we could get the best of both units in one.

    • Dana

      Did yours arrive with the little clamp which can be used to mount the Sharpener quite securely to a table top? Or is that not what you meant by a permanent mounting?

      • It sure did, but it’s been a while, and I can’t remember what I meant — probably a mount strong enough to hold a child up who wanted to hang on. :)

  10. Michael R.

    Just received this is the mail and after using it on about 10 pencils – It stopped working. It did a great job and then I emptied the bottom tray and tried again – and it does not grind anymore. really disappointing. I took the handle out and re-attached…but no luck. any suggestions? thanks!

    • Michael R.

      never mind! I found a small broken piece of pencil tip inside and now it’s working! sorry to bother…took me awhile to trouble shoot. Now I know :)

  11. Krysiulek

    I just got a Helix desktop pencil sharpener that is very similar to the one reviewed here. The same method of putting pencil in (extractable pencil holder), same auto-stop mechanism, and five point settings (though the differences in these do not seem to be as great as in the illustrated guide on the sharpener).

    The Helix doesn’t make the pencils needle-sharp, either. It seems to work very well, and is also a sturdy metal construction, as is the one in this review. It has the same large recepticle for shavings, too, and clamp so that it can be mounted on a table, though it can be simple held on the desktop, as this model is (see video).

    All these similarities make me wonder about the originality of the ideas behind the Classroom Friendly model, since the English Helix company has been in existence since the 19th century.

    Although I bought mine through Amazon.co.uk a couple of weeks ago for about 10 GBP, I see today that there are no more in stock. I would recommend the Helix, based on my extensive testing today. It does mark the pencils with its gripping mechanism, as this one does, but that isn’t a major problem.

  12. I have one that was left to me by my Grandfather who had it in his home office. He passed away in the early ’70s and he had it for a while before that. The “retro” look is not an accident, it has not changed at all for at least the last 50 years.
    I’d guess Japanese design, and perhaps early years are Japanese made. It has that nice robustness and simplicity of truly good engineering.
    I use my 50+ year old unit often, it will keep going for another 50 I reckon.

    • Ooops! Just checked the bottom of mine and it clearly says “JAPAN” in stamped letters. “CARL ANGEL-5″ is the name of it embossed on the plastic waste tray. Wonder what ANGEL-1 to -4 were?

  13. Jeanna

    I ordered 3 of these for my teachers. We loved them at first, but after a few months started getting real dull and caused the leads to break off. I don’t want to spend that musch to replace the insdes, only if they are going to last 2 months.

  14. Sorry to hear, Jeanna. I’d suggest contacting the seller Troy via his site.
    I see they have replacement blades these days, too. :)

  15. Kim

    I have ordered five of these over the last few years and used them in my classrooms (first in middle school with 7th graders and lately in 3rd grade), always buying them from Troy. They always work great at first but after a while (a few months or so), they start having problems. While the blades tend to remain sharp and are able to produce a very nice point, what always seems to happen is the tension on the pencil that pulls it into the blades seems to relax, causing the pencil to not sharpen entirely. I have found if I put my left hand on top of the sharpener with my pinky or ring finger pulling the pencil guide towards the blades, it will continue to sharpen. Of course, using the sharpener fifty or more times a day, over the course of a school year, would probably cause most anything to wear out.

    Oh, and I don’t let my students sharpen colored pencils with these, as that almost always causes the points to break off and jam the machine.

  16. T.

    Best sharpener I’ve ever used for No. 2 pencils!

    Do not, however, attempt to sharpen any colored pencils in this as the sharpener will surely clog with the broken off points. Colored pencils must be sharpened by a KUM, Staedtler, or Alvin Bullet hand sharpener if you care about them!

  17. Martha

    “Lying in bed would be an altogether perfect and supreme experience if only one had a colored pencil long enough to draw on the ceiling.”
    G.K. Chesterton

  18. We have a new style pencil sharpener (item ELM 148) which also produced and sold in Japan market for many years, and we are now planning to sell this pencil sharpener to the whole world.

    Our sharpener has the same good quality as Carl pencil sharpener, but a little smaller in size.

    below is the website for this item.

    http://dgyizhimei.en.alibaba.com/product/277876880-209648251/ELM_148_Metal_Pencil_Sharpener_hand_pencil_sharpener_hand_crank_pencil_sharpener_hand_held_pencil_sharpener.html

  19. Pat Bailey

    I mounted mine to a 14″ long x 4″ wide piece of hardwood. Then I use a 3″ C-clamp to hold the board firmly against a desk or table, not marring the surface of either. This makes it “almost” permanently mounted and it works great! Once a week I go around Esquire Hills Elementary School to sharpen pencils (and to add a piece or two of lead if the pencil happens to be a mechanical type). The kids’ reactions to how fast and how sharp are priceless!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *